You told them it was fine. You meant it. Then a song comes on, or someone uses the same phrase, and the whole evening plays back in your head. Now you’re wondering whether you forgave at all, or whether you only said the words.
This post separates three things that can get packed into one: forgiving, forgetting and trusting again. It covers three studies on how they relate, a short list of questions to sort out where you stand, and a way to talk it through with one person. A word written on a piece of paper is enough for that part.
The short answer
Yes. Forgiving and forgetting are separate, and you can do the first without the second. Forgiving is a decision about the person: you stop holding the act against them. Forgetting happens in memory, and it can’t be decided the same way. Trusting again is a third step, and it depends on what the other person does next.
When the three get treated as one, a returning memory can feel like proof that forgiveness failed. Kept apart, the memory is a memory. The question becomes what you do when it comes back.
What forgiving may do to memory
One small experiment suggests the order runs the other way: forgiving first, forgetting later. Saima Noreen, Raynette Bierman and Malcolm MacLeod asked 30 people to imagine being hurt in a series of made-up situations and to say whether they’d forgive each one. Then the participants practiced thinking about some of the situations and pushing others out of mind. They forgot more of the forgiven situations they had pushed away. For situations they hadn’t forgiven, pushing them away made no difference to what they remembered (Noreen et al. 2014).
The study used imagined hurts in a lab, with 30 participants, so treat it as a lead. Its pattern is still worth knowing. In the study, pushing away a hurt that hadn’t been forgiven left the memory as it was.
What replaying does to forgiving
Replaying the hurt is the part that pulls hardest the other way. Michael McCullough, Giacomo Bono and Lindsey Root followed people over time after someone had hurt them, in three studies. At times when people thought about the offense more than usual, they forgave less. The link ran through anger toward the person, and in the third study the rise in rumination tended to come before the drop in forgiveness (McCullough et al. 2007).
That gives a practical reading. A memory that shows up once is a memory. A memory you replay, adding lines you wish you’d said, can feed the anger again. Noticing the difference can be a first step. You can let the scene arrive and decline the rerun.
Trusting again is a separate step
Trust depends on the other person, and research on forgiving points the same way. Laura Luchies, Eli Finkel, James McNulty and Madoka Kumashiro ran four studies, including one that followed newly married couples over their first five years. Forgiving went with more self-respect when the partner had made amends or signaled that the forgiver would be safe and valued. Without that signal, forgiving went with less self-respect (Luchies et al. 2010).
The researchers called this the doormat effect. The finding leaves forgiving in place and points to the gap between forgiving and opening the door wide again. You can let go of the grudge and still decide what the person gets access to now, based on what they’ve done since.
Questions to sort out where you stand
These questions work alone with a pen, or with someone you trust asking them. Pick one hurt and keep it specific: a place, a year, a person.
- When the memory comes back, what’s the first feeling: anger, sadness or something else?
- Is the memory the same each time, or does your version keep growing?
- What would forgiving this person change for you, if anything?
- What did they do after the hurt, and what did they leave undone?
- What would they need to do for you to trust them with this again?
- Is there a part of your life where they still have access, and does that feel right?
- Who else knows about this, and does telling it help or keep it fresh?
- What would you like to remember from this, a year from now?
Questions 4 and 5 belong to trust. Questions 1 and 2 belong to the memory. If your answers to the two pairs look different, that’s the split this post is about.
One word at the table
A second way in is to put one word down and look at it from several sides. The Thesis die has six faces: MEMORIES · BODY · PEOPLE · VALUES · CHILDHOOD · FUTURE. The only instruction is “Look at the word from that side.”
Forgiveness has a Door on its other side. For this reader the Door is the useful side. Forgiving can close a door on the grudge while another door, the one to your daily life, stays half open. Talking about a door from childhood or a door you stopped knocking on can say more than talking about forgiveness in general.
Trust has a Window on its other side. Trust is the step that comes from evidence, and a window is where you watch from before you open anything. The Window side can bring up what you see now that you couldn’t see then.
Boundaries has Shoes on its other side. Boundaries are what’s left when you’ve forgiven and don’t trust yet: where someone may walk and where they may not. The Shoes side brings up who takes them off at your door and who keeps them on.
Try it with one person
A hurt said out loud to someone who wasn’t involved can be easier to sort. They can hear which part is the memory and which part is the grievance, because they don’t share either. One friend at a kitchen table is enough.
Before you start, agree how passing works. The Thesis rules open with “Before you start, agree together how passing works.” For a word this close, the right to pass matters more than any question. Then take turns: draw a card, choose a side, roll the die, and say as much or as little as feels right.
The rule card gives three follow-ups that fit every word: What did that feel like? Who else was there? Has it always meant that to you? For this topic the third one does the most. It can show whether forgiveness has moved over time, even when the memory hasn’t. For ways to ask about painful things gently, see how to ask sensitive questions. For what research links to forgiving in the first place, see what makes people forgive.
What to do this week
Write three words on a piece of paper: forgive, forget, trust. Next to each, write one line about the hurt you’re carrying. Leave “forget” blank if nothing fits. That blank is fine. Memory sets its own pace.
The next time the memory comes back, name it as a memory and let it pass without the rerun. Then tell one person about the line you wrote next to “trust”, and let them ask one follow-up. “A short answer is a full answer. You can always ask for more.”
See the rules and the box, or open the free online table. The cards above have their own pages: Forgiveness, Trust and Boundaries. For playing with a few close people, see Thesis for friends. The research behind the deck explains where the words came from.