What makes people forgive: empathy, apology and intent

You apologized. You meant it, and you suggested meeting up. Months later the other person still treats you as the one who hurt them. Or you’re on the other side: someone said sorry, and you can’t tell why it didn’t land.

This post explains what research links to forgiveness, in plain words. It covers one large review of 175 studies, one study on what an apology needs, and a way to talk about forgiveness with someone close. The deck helps with the last part, and a word written on a napkin works too.

The short answer

Four things stand out. People forgive more when they feel empathy for the person who hurt them, when they get an apology, and when they believe the harm wasn’t intended. They forgive less while they’re still angry. The situation counts for more than the forgiving person’s character.

That comes from a meta-analysis by Ryan Fehr, Michele Gelfand and Monisha Nag. They pooled 175 studies with 26,006 participants and looked at one victim forgiving one offender. They tested 22 factors that might go with forgiveness (Fehr et al. 2010).

Four factors in plain words

The review reports each factor as a correlation, a number from −1 to 1. Zero means no link. The further from zero, the stronger the link. A minus sign means that more of the factor goes with less forgiveness. These are links: they show what tends to travel with forgiveness, and they leave open what causes what.

  • Empathy, r = .51. The more people felt for the offender in that moment, the more they forgave. This was the strongest of the four.
  • Intent, r = −.49. The more deliberate the harm seemed, the less people forgave. What counts here is how the act looked to the person hurt.
  • Apology, r = .42. An apology went with more forgiveness.
  • Anger, r = −.41. The angrier people were about the offense, the less they forgave.

Two results from the same review are easy to miss. Gender made almost no difference (r = .01), and age made little (r = .06). And the empathy and anger in the list are states, what someone feels about this offense now, rather than lifelong traits. Situational factors explained more of forgiveness than the victim’s personality did (Fehr et al. 2010).

Why the friend still hasn’t forgiven

The four factors point to why a sincere apology can stall. An apology is one of them, and it sits next to three others the person who apologized can’t control. If the other person still reads the act as deliberate, the apology competes with that reading. If they’re still angry, the anger pulls the other way.

Empathy has the strongest link of the four, and knowing what the other person was going through may feed it. A short “sorry” says little about that. A story does: what was happening that week, what you thought, what you didn’t see. That story also speaks to intent, because it shows how the act looked from inside.

The review also found early signs that the way studies asked mattered. When people read an imagined scenario, thoughts about the offense showed stronger links. When they recalled a real one from their own life, feelings showed stronger links (Fehr et al. 2010). That hints that with a real hurt, a slow conversation may do more than a well-argued case.

What an apology needs

A separate study looked at what goes into an apology. Roy Lewicki, Robert Lount and Beth Polin asked 755 people to rate apologies in two studies: 333 adults online and 422 students. Everyone read the same workplace scenario, a job candidate apologizing for a past mistake. The apologies held one to six parts (Ohio State News 2016).

The six parts were rated in this order:

  1. Acknowledgment of responsibility, rated most important.
  2. An offer of repair, second.
  3. Expression of regret, tied for third.
  4. Explanation of what went wrong, tied for third.
  5. Declaration of repentance, tied for third.
  6. A request for forgiveness, rated least important.

Apologies with more parts were rated as more effective in both studies. The finding that stands out is the last one. Asking “Can you forgive me?” did the least, and Lewicki called it the part to leave out if you have to. One reading: it puts the next step on the person who was hurt. “I did it, and here’s how I’ll fix it” leaves that step with the person who apologized.

The scenario was about trust at work, so treat the ranking as a lead for friendships and families. It fits the meta-analysis, though. Taking responsibility speaks to the question of intent, and an offer of repair is something the other person can watch happen.

Questions to talk about forgiveness

These questions work for a few people after dinner, or for one person with a notebook. They start with small, old hurts and move toward bigger ones. Answer with a story where you can: a place, a year, a person.

  1. What did forgiving look like in your family when you were a child?
  2. When did someone forgive you faster than you expected?
  3. What’s the best apology you’ve ever received?
  4. Which apology didn’t work on you, and what was missing?
  5. Have you ever forgiven someone without telling them?
  6. When did you understand someone’s reasons long after the fact?
  7. What’s the difference between forgiving someone and trusting them again?
  8. Is there something you’ve forgiven but still bring up?
  9. What words would let you put one old hurt down?

Question 6 is the empathy factor in story form. Question 7 can open a long conversation, because the two can happen far apart.

One word at the table

A second way in is to put one word on the table and look at it from several sides. The Thesis die has six faces: MEMORIES · BODY · PEOPLE · VALUES · CHILDHOOD · FUTURE. The only instruction is “Look at the word from that side.”

Forgiveness
Door
Card 40: Forgiveness / Door. Tap to turn it over.

Forgiveness has a Door on its other side. Choose the idea when the group wants to talk about apologies, reasons and second chances. Choose the Door when a story is easier: a door someone slammed, a door left open, the door of a home you stopped visiting. Doors carry the moment before a conversation.

Anger
Ring
Card 22: Anger / Ring. Tap to turn it over.

Anger has a Ring on its other side. The review links anger to less forgiveness, and talking about anger once it has cooled can be easier than during it. The Ring side brings up promises, weddings and things handed down, which leads back to who was angry at whom, and why.

Trust
Window
Card 34: Trust / Window. Tap to turn it over.

Trust has a Window on its other side. Forgiveness and trust can come apart: someone forgives and still checks. The Window side lets players talk about what they can see now that they couldn’t see before.

Roll the die

Before you start, agree how passing works. The Thesis rules open with “Before you start, agree together how passing works.” For a heavy word, that agreement matters more than any question. Then the turn is the usual one: draw a card, choose a side, roll the die, and say as much or as little as feels right.

The rule card offers three follow-ups that fit every word: What did that feel like? Who else was there? Has it always meant that to you? For Forgiveness, the first one does most of the work. It invites the feelings that the research links to forgiving, without asking anyone to forgive. If you’d like more on asking about painful topics gently, see how to ask sensitive questions.

What to do now

If you’re waiting to be forgiven, look at your apology against the list above. Check whether it names what you did and offers a repair, and whether it ends on a request. Then tell the story of that week, if the other person wants to hear it, and leave the decision with them.

If you’re the one deciding, try the Door side first. Say what happened, from one side of the die, to someone who’ll ask one follow-up. “A short answer is a full answer. You can always ask for more.”

See the rules and the box, or open the free online table. The cards above have their own pages: Forgiveness, Anger and Trust. For playing with a few close people, see Thesis for friends. For more on the research, see the research behind the deck.