You put honesty on the agenda, and the room goes one of two ways. Either members argue about whether white lies are fine in general, or one person feels called on to confess something big before anyone else has spoken. Neither is the session you planned. Honesty activities hold together when the truths start small, stay first-person, and grow only as far as each member chooses. This guide gives five rounds for one session in a therapy group, a recovery meeting or a peer support circle, in the order you run them.
Every round works with the word written on an index card. The examples use the Thesis card deck, where Honesty is card 14. You know your group and its purpose, and you decide how far an activity like this goes in it. Thesis is a conversation format and makes no clinical claims.
Why honesty is a hard topic to open
People can expect honesty to cost more than it does. In a three-day field study by Levine and Cohen, people asked to be completely honest found it more pleasant and more connecting than they had predicted. In two lab experiments, people who disclosed personal information or gave honest negative feedback overestimated how badly the other person would react (Levine and Cohen 2018).
That gap shows up in a circle. A member weighs a true sentence, guesses the room will judge it, and says something safer. A first round with a low cost gives everyone a chance to test that guess on something small. The rounds below raise the stakes slowly, and every one has a way out.
Before the first round: two agreements
Two agreements carry the whole session. The first is about passing. The Thesis rule card opens with it: “Before you start, agree together how passing works.” The second is about what leaves the room. The card puts it in one line: “What is said at the table stays at the table.” Tie that line to the confidentiality agreement your group already has.
Add one agreement that belongs to this topic: honesty here means honest about yourself. Nobody uses the session to tell another member a hard truth about them. That keeps the activity a sharing format and keeps it from turning into a verdict on someone in the room.
Round 1: One small true thing
Each member says one true thing about their week that they’d usually leave out. It can be small: a meal skipped, a call not returned, a good moment they didn’t mention to anyone. One sentence counts. The rule card says it: “A short answer is a full answer. You can always ask for more.”
The round works because the truth is real and the stakes are low. The host goes first. In Thesis, “Whoever suggested the game goes first,” and in a group that can be you. Pick something plain, say it in one sentence, and stop. The length of your share sets the length for the room.
Honesty sits on the back of Radio. The pair gives a member two doors. One leads to a truth they told or kept back. The other leads to a kitchen radio that was always on, or a station a parent wouldn’t let anyone change. A member who isn’t ready for the idea side can take the Radio and still have a full turn.
Round 2: White lies, in your own life
Ask each member about one white lie they told recently and why they told it. Keep the question on the reason. “To be kind,” “to avoid a fight” and “because I was tired” are all answers, and none gets judged.
This round is where a group can drift into debate. Someone says white lies are fine, someone else says they never are, and the talk moves to the general case. Bring it back with one question: “When was the last time that happened to you?” A first-person scene keeps the share honest in the sense this session cares about.
These questions work for this round and the next, one per turn:
- What’s a white lie you told this month, and who was it for?
- Who in your life gets the most honest version of you?
- When did telling the truth go better than you expected?
- What’s something you say “I’m fine” about?
- Who taught you what honesty means?
- When is it hard for you to be honest with yourself?
- What’s a truth you waited a long time to say?
- What does honesty sound like from someone you trust?
- When did someone’s honesty help you?
- What would you say here today if it were easier?
Round 3: The truth you delayed
Each member describes a time they waited to say something true, and what happened when they said it or didn’t. This is the deepest round, so it comes in the middle, after two lighter ones, with time left to come down.
Follow-ups keep it gentle. The rule card lists three: What did that feel like? Who else was there? Has it always meant that to you? Use those and stop there. A member who gave a short answer can be asked one, and can pass on it.
Trust is on the back of Window. In this round the word can come up anyway, because a delayed truth can be about whether someone could hear it. A member might talk about a person they could tell anything to, or about a window they looked out of while waiting for a call. Either side fits the round.
Round 4: Honest with the group
Each member names one thing they’ve held back in this group and decides whether to say it. Some members may say “there is something” and leave it there. That counts. Naming that a thing exists is an honest share, and the group doesn’t ask what it is.
This round turns the topic toward the room. It also gives the host information: if several members say the same kind of thing is hard to say here, the group can talk about why, in a later session.
Shame is on the back of Letter. Shame can be what stands between a person and a true sentence, which is why it fits this round. It’s also a heavy word. A member can take the Letter side and talk about a letter they wrote and never sent, or one they kept for years. Before this card is played, a one-line reminder of the pass agreement helps.
Round 5: What I heard
Close with the round from the last Thesis rule card: “each player names one thing they discovered about someone at the table today.” In an honesty session it does a second job. Members hear that what they said landed, which answers the guess they made in round 1.
Keep it to one sentence per person. Nobody comments on the sentence. For more closing formats, see check-out questions for group therapy.
Run it with the online table
If the group meets online or has a shared screen, the online table deals the cards and rolls the die. Agree on passing first, then play round 1 with Honesty on the table.
The die has six faces: MEMORIES · BODY · PEOPLE · VALUES · CHILDHOOD · FUTURE. The only instruction is “Look at the word from that side.” A member who rolls a side they don’t want can pass on it like any other prompt.
Before your next session, write one sentence on an index card: the honest thing you’ll say in round 1. Then go first.
For running the game in a session, see Thesis for therapy groups. The cards above have their own pages: Honesty, Trust and Shame. You can play online for free, see the rules and the box, or read the research behind the deck. For a session on limits, see a boundaries activity for group therapy. Related: gratitude activity for group therapy: four rounds that stay concrete. Related: respect group therapy activities: five rounds for adults. Related: family group therapy activities: five rounds that let each member choose the distance.