The facilitator says, “Let’s go around and share one thing we’re grateful for.” The first person says family. The second says health. A few turns in, people repeat what they heard, and someone who had a hard week says “my coffee” and goes quiet. The topic works. The format asks for a feeling on demand and gets a list of safe nouns. Gratitude works as a group topic when the round asks for something specific: a person, an object, a moment, or a mixed feeling. Below are four rounds for therapy and support groups, ten questions, and a session plan.
The rounds work with a whiteboard or an index card. The examples use the Thesis card deck, where Gratitude is card 31. A word written on paper works the same way.
Why “one thing you’re grateful for” stalls
An open gratitude prompt has a right answer built in. The expected tone is clear, so people can give the answer that sounds right and skip the one that’s true. A member in the middle of a loss hears a request to feel better on schedule. Some may stay quiet, and others may perform.
Gratitude exercises can also land differently across cultures. In a six-week study, Layous and colleagues assigned 250 US and 270 South Korean participants to write gratitude letters, do kind acts, or do a neutral task for the first half of the study. The US participants gained in well-being from gratitude. The South Korean participants gained less from gratitude, though they gained from kind acts about as much as the US group. The authors suggest the letters may have brought up mixed feelings, such as indebtedness alongside thanks (Layous et al. 2013). That’s a study of well-being exercises, not of groups. It’s still a reason to leave room in the round for gratitude with a debt attached.
Round 1: One person, one reason
Ask for a person and a reason instead of a list: “Name someone you’re grateful to, and one thing they did.” The detail does the work. A neighbor who carried groceries up the stairs says more than “my neighbors”.
The speaker can misjudge how the thanks would land. In three experiments, Kumar and Epley had people write gratitude letters and predict how recipients would feel. Writers overestimated how awkward recipients would feel and underestimated how positive they would feel. Those predictions were linked to how willing people were to express gratitude (Kumar and Epley 2018). A member who says “they probably don’t remember” may be making the same guess. A follow-up from the rule card opens it up: Who else was there?
Round 2: Start from the object
Every Thesis card has an idea on one side and an everyday thing on the other, and a player can choose either. For a gratitude session, the thing side gives people a way in that asks for no feeling at all.
Gratitude is on the back of Fence. A fence can be one a parent built, a neighbor’s fence that leaned into the yard for years, or one a person climbed to get out. Gratitude can show up halfway through the story without being asked for. A member who isn’t ready for the idea side can stay with the fence for the whole turn, and that counts: “A short answer is a full answer. You can always ask for more.”
Round 3: Gratitude with something attached
Some gratitude comes with a bill. A parent paid for school and still brings it up. A friend lent money that can’t be paid back yet. A group that has permission for mixed gratitude may hear more honest turns. Name it before the round: thanks, debt, resentment, and relief can sit in the same sentence.
Duty is on the back of Ticket. Next to Gratitude, it shows the other half of the word: what people feel they owe. A ticket can be one somebody bought for you, one you paid back, or one you never used. Each of those stories can lead to the same question of who owes whom.
Round 4: Thanks said in the room
The last round turns gratitude toward the table. Thesis ends with a closing round where “each player names one thing they discovered about someone at the table today.” For a gratitude session, a group can add one line: something another member said in this session that they’re glad they heard.
Keep it to one sentence per person, with no reply from the person named. A thank-you that needs no answer can be easier to give and easier to take. Members who don’t want to name anyone can pass, as agreed at the start.
Kindness is on the back of Book. It works as a backup for this round. A member can talk about a kindness from a stranger or a book someone lent them. That keeps the thank-you away from the room on a day when the room feels too close.
Questions for a gratitude session
These questions keep the topic specific. Pick three or four for one session and save the rest.
- Who did something for you that they’ve probably forgotten?
- What’s an object you still have because someone gave it to you?
- When did you thank someone too late?
- What are you grateful for that’s hard to say out loud?
- Who are you grateful to and still angry with?
- What did someone teach you without meaning to?
- What’s a small thing from this week that went right?
- Who would you thank if they could hear you now?
- What kind of gratitude were you taught as a kid?
- When has being told to be grateful made things harder?
Question 10 matters in a group where some members are under pressure to feel thankful. It gives them a place inside the topic, where the usual round leaves them outside it.
A session plan
The rounds fit one session in this order:
- Pass agreement. “Before you start, agree together how passing works.”
- Round 1. One person, one reason.
- Round 2 or 3. Draw cards, choose a side, talk.
- Round 4. One sentence each about someone at the table.
Leave a pause after a heavy turn before the next speaker starts. For how to hold that pause, see silence in group therapy.
You know your group and its limits, and you decide whether a gratitude week fits where members are. Thesis is a conversation format and makes no clinical claims. Some weeks a member will be grieving or angry, and the round still belongs to them. “There are no right answers.”
Try a round before the session
Open the online table, draw until Gratitude or Duty comes up, and play one turn yourself, from either side.
The die has six faces: MEMORIES · BODY · PEOPLE · VALUES · CHILDHOOD · FUTURE. The only instruction is “Look at the word from that side.”
Before the session, write the four rounds on one card and decide whether round 2 or round 3 fits this group. For more on running the game with a group, see Thesis for therapy groups. The three cards above have their own pages: Gratitude, Duty, and Kindness. You can play online for free, see the rules and the box, or read the research behind the deck. For more ways to end a session, see check-out questions for group therapy. Related: A boundaries activity for group therapy: one session, one word. Related: honesty group therapy activities: five rounds for one session. Related: shame in group work: a format for facilitators.