How men can talk about feelings with friends

You’ve known these guys for years. You meet for the game, a beer, a run on Sunday. You know their teams, their cars and their jobs. You found out a friend’s father was ill when someone mentioned it in the group chat, weeks after the fact. Nobody kept it a secret. There was no moment in the evening where it would have come up.

Men can talk about feelings with friends without a big talk or a new kind of evening. What helps is a small, fixed slot inside the usual one: one word on the table, a concrete thing to start from, and one follow-up question. This guide sets that up. It works with the Thesis deck, the free online table, or a word written on a coaster.

What the numbers show

In a 2021 survey of American adults, 30 percent of men said they’d had a private conversation with a friend in the past week where they shared their personal feelings. Among women it was 48 percent. In the same week, 21 percent of men had received emotional support from a friend, against 41 percent of women (Cox 2021, Survey Center on American Life).

Those numbers describe one week. A regular hangout is where that week could look different: the group that meets often and still talks about the same few things.

Why it doesn’t come up

The usual advice is “open up more.” It gets skipped for plain reasons that have to do with the setting.

  • No slot. A match, a bar or a run has its own script. Raising something personal means breaking that script, and it can be hard to be the one who does it.
  • It sounds heavy. “Can we talk about something real” sounds like an announcement. The friend braces for bad news.
  • Nobody goes first. Each man may wait for a sign that it’s fine. The sign doesn’t come, because the others are waiting too.
  • No second question. When someone does say something, the reply can be a joke or a “that sucks, man,” and the topic closes.

Expectations play a part too. In experiments where strangers talked to each other, people overestimated how awkward a deep conversation would be. Afterward, they felt more connected to their deep conversation partners (Kardas et al. 2021). The same research found that people predicted better with close friends, whose interest is easier to know. With old friends, the missing slot in the evening may matter more.

Start from a thing

A word gives the talk a place to start that isn’t you. Each Thesis card has an idea on one side and an everyday thing on the other. The thing side is the easy way in for a group of friends who’d rather not start with a feeling.

Say the card is Courage with Bicycle on the back. Nobody has to talk about courage. One friend talks about the bike he rode to school. Another about the first time he rode down the big hill without brakes. A third about teaching his kid last summer and letting go of the seat. That last one is a story about fear and pride, told through a bike. Things bring up places and people, and the feelings come along with them.

This can also fit friendships that run side by side, around an activity. The card is one more thing on the table, next to the drinks.

How to bring it to your friends

These steps fit a kitchen table, a bar corner or a cabin weekend:

  1. Pick the right night. A small group, somewhere you can hear each other. A loud bar during a match makes it hard.
  2. Say it plainly. “I’ve got this card game, one word each, it’s quick.” Keep it light, and don’t explain why.
  3. Agree on passing. The rules open with “Before you start, agree together how passing works.” A pass without a reason, or a flip to the thing side, keeps it easy.
  4. Go first, and keep it short. The person who brings the game goes first. A short story about a real thing sets the level for everyone else.
  5. Ask one follow-up. When a friend answers, ask one more question before anyone jokes.
  6. Stop while it’s good. One round is enough the first time. “Play for as long as it feels good.”
Roll the die

The online table works on a phone in the middle. It draws, flips and rolls, so nobody needs the box to try it.

The follow-up does the work

The second question is where a friend feels heard. The rule card gives three that fit every word:

What did that feel like? Who else was there? Has it always meant that to you?

A short answer is fine. The rule card says so: “A short answer is a full answer. You can always ask for more.” One follow-up, then a pause, gives a friend room to add something. If he doesn’t, the next person goes. Jokes can come back after that, and they will.

One word, six angles

The Thesis die has six faces, each a plain word: MEMORIES · BODY · PEOPLE · VALUES · CHILDHOOD · FUTURE. The only instruction is “Look at the word from that side.” With a die, the same card turns into a different conversation each roll, so the evening doesn’t depend on one good question.

Questions to start with friends

If you’d rather use questions than a die, these go from light to deeper. Pick two or three for one evening:

  1. What’s a thing you owned at 15 that you still think about?
  2. Who taught you to ride, swim or fix something?
  3. What did your dad do on a Saturday?
  4. Where were you for a match you still remember?
  5. When did you last feel proud of something nobody saw?
  6. What’s something you were scared of that you did anyway?
  7. Who’s a friend you lost touch with, and why?
  8. What’s harder at your age than you expected?
  9. What would you tell yourself at 20?
  10. What do you want the next ten years to look like?

Three cards that work for men’s friendships

Each of these three cards has an easy thing side and an idea that goes further.

Friendship
Ball
Card 21: Friendship / Ball. Tap to turn it over.

Friendship has Ball on its other side. The ball side is home ground: school yards, pickup games, a ball kicked against a garage door all summer. Those stories can include a friend, and from there the idea side is one step away. Who was your best friend at 12, and what happened to him?

Courage
Bicycle
Card 29: Courage / Bicycle. Tap to turn it over.

Courage has Bicycle on its other side. The bicycle side brings up first rides, crashes and long trips. The idea side lets a friend talk about a risk he took, a job he left or a hard call he made, without calling it a feeling.

Work
Stone
Card 27: Work / Stone. Tap to turn it over.

Work has Stone on its other side. Work may be the topic friends already share, so this card starts where the talk can go anyway. A roll of the die moves it somewhere new. The stone side goes to beaches, walls and a stone someone kept from a trip.

Close with one thing each

When the evening winds down, end the way every game of Thesis ends: “When the group is ready to stop, finish with one last round: each player names one thing they discovered about someone at the table today.” It’s quick, and it tells each friend that someone listened.

Next time the group meets, bring one word. See the rules and the box, or open the online table. The cards above have their own pages: Friendship, Courage and Work. For more on playing with a group, see Thesis for friends. For the studies behind the deck, see the research page. If the trouble starts with the catch-up itself, see what comes after small talk. Related: how to talk about failure with friends.