How to start a men's group: the first three meetings

You’ve asked a handful of men if they’d come to a group, and the answers came back “maybe”. Now you have a date, a room and no plan for what happens once everyone sits down. Starting a men’s group comes down to three meetings with three jobs. The first sets the rules and lets people meet. The second gives the talking a shape. The third asks the group whether it wants to continue. This guide walks through each one, for anyone hosting a peer group of men for the first time.

The plan works with any prompt. The middle meeting uses the Thesis card deck as an example, but a word written on an index card does the same job.

Before the first meeting

The work starts before anyone arrives. Write one sentence about what the group is for, such as “Men in their 30s and 40s who want a place to talk about work, family and getting older.” That sentence is your invitation, and it tells people what they’re saying yes to.

Invite more men than you expect to show up. Some of the “maybe” answers can turn into no-shows. Ask in person or by direct message, since a group chat announcement can be easy to ignore.

Settle four things before the invite goes out:

  • Where. A quiet room with a door: a living room, a back room in a community center, a library room.
  • When. A fixed evening, a fixed length and a fixed rhythm, so nobody has to ask when the next one is.
  • How many. Enough men to fill a circle when a couple cancel.
  • Who hosts. You do, for the first three meetings. Rotating the host can come later.

Men’s groups don’t all look alike. Some meet to talk in a circle. Others meet to build something side by side, as in Men’s Sheds, where men work on shared projects such as woodwork. A scoping review of 31 papers on Men’s Sheds and similar activities for older men found limited evidence of effects on mental health and wellbeing, and no conclusive evidence yet that they improve health (Milligan et al. 2016). It named accessibility, a range of activities, local support and skilled coordination as key elements of success. Those four are a useful checklist for a new group of any kind.

Meeting 1: Rules and names

The first meeting is about the room, not the depth. A man who is new to sharing in a group may stay quiet because he’s unsure what’s expected or worried about saying the wrong thing. Clear rules answer that question before anyone has to talk.

Open with a short round of names and one plain fact each, such as where they grew up or what they do on a Saturday. Then read the ground rules out loud and ask the group to change or add to them. A short set helps a group settle in:

  • Speak from your own experience.
  • No advice unless someone asks for it.
  • Let a man finish before you speak.
  • Silence is allowed.
  • What is said here stays here.
  • Anyone can pass on any turn.

Write the final version on a sheet of paper and bring it to every meeting. Then close with one round where each man says what made him say yes to coming. Keep this meeting short. Ending on time tells the group the schedule holds.

Meeting 2: A low-pressure middle

The second meeting is where the talking starts. A prompt helps here, because it gives every man the same starting point and takes away the question of what to say. A card game gives that prompt a shape: one word on the table, one man at a time, and a clear end to each turn.

The Thesis rules start with the pass: “Before you start, agree together how passing works.” Your group already did that in meeting 1, so read the agreement out again and play. Each man draws a card and chooses a side, the idea or the everyday thing. Thesis is for 2–6 players, so a bigger group splits into two tables.

The rule card sets the pace: “Say as much or as little as feels right.” The others ask what they’re curious about, using short open questions such as What did that feel like?, Who else was there? and Has it always meant that to you? A man who wants to keep it light can talk about the object. A man who wants to go further can take the idea.

Adulthood
Coin
Card 18: Adulthood / Coin. Tap to turn it over.

Adulthood sits on the back of Coin. It’s a good card for a men’s group, because it opens the question of when each man first felt grown up, and who decided that. A player who’d rather stay on the light side can talk about a coin he kept, or his first pay.

Work
Stone
Card 27: Work / Stone. Tap to turn it over.

Work is on the back of Stone. In a first round, work can be an easy topic to start with. On a card, it can lead past the job title to what a man carries home from it. Stone gives a second way in: a stone he picked up somewhere and still has.

Roll the die

The die adds one more step. It has six faces: MEMORIES · BODY · PEOPLE · VALUES · CHILDHOOD · FUTURE. The only instruction is “Look at the word from that side.” End the meeting with the game’s last round: “each player names one thing they discovered about someone at the table today.”

Meeting 3: Decide together

The third meeting hands the group back to the men in it. Start with an open round without cards: one thing since the last meeting each man wants to mention. Some groups will be ready for this. If the round stays thin, bring the deck back for a second half.

Then ask the group four plain questions about the format:

  1. Do we keep meeting?
  2. Same day, same length, same place?
  3. Do we keep a prompt, like the cards, or talk without one?
  4. Who hosts the next three meetings?

Take the answers as they come and write them down. If a man says this isn’t for him, thank him and let him go. A small group of men who want to be there is still a group.

Why the first meetings feel awkward

The first meetings of a new group can feel stiff. A man may feel embarrassed about why he came, or wait to see what the others say. A structure gives everyone something to do in that gap. Over three meetings, the rules can become familiar, and the men may start to know each other’s stories.

The research on men’s groups is thin. A narrative review of Men’s Sheds literature found 5 reports and 19 articles, and the research base was mostly descriptive surveys or small qualitative studies (Wilson and Cordier 2013). So treat any promise of health effects with care. What you can describe is the format: who meets, how often, and what they do.

You know your group and its limits. If a man is in crisis, a peer group isn’t the place to handle it alone. Agree in meeting 1 on what you’ll do and where you’ll point him. Thesis is a conversation format and makes no clinical claims.

Your next step

Write your one-sentence purpose and your ground rules on one sheet of paper today. Send the invitation with a date for meeting 1, and add the dates of meetings 2 and 3, so men know what they’re agreeing to.

For the second meeting, you can play online for free on a shared screen or see the rules and the box. The two cards above have their own pages, Adulthood and Work, and so does Friendship, a good word for the third meeting. For more on using the game in a group, see Thesis for therapy groups. When a few men stay silent through every round, see how to get quiet group members to talk. The research behind the deck is on the research page. Related: group therapy icebreakers for adults: start with one word.