You’ve sat next to her at a few dinners now. You know where she grew up, what she does for work, and that her brother lives in Lisbon. You have no idea what she’s hoping for this year, or what keeps her awake. You know a lot of facts and still don’t know her.
This post gives a simple map for that gap: three levels of getting to know someone, how to tell which one you’re on, and three questions for each step up.
Three levels of knowing a person
The map comes from the psychologist Dan McAdams. In 1995 he described personality at three levels. Level one is broad traits, the kind of description that yields what he called a “psychology of the stranger.” Level two is personal concerns: goals, values, ways of coping, things that depend on time, place and role. Level three is identity as an inner life story that ties together the past, the present and the expected future (McAdams 1995).
McAdams wrote about describing a person, not about how conversations go. Read as a guide to talk, the three levels turn into three kinds of question:
- Level one: facts. Where they live, what they do, who’s in their family.
- Level two: goals and worries. What they’re working toward, and what’s weighing on them.
- Level three: the story. How they make sense of where they’ve been and where they’re going.
The behavioral researcher Vanessa Van Edwards, who builds her conversation advice on this model, suggests a quick test: you’ve reached level two with someone when you know what gets them up in the morning and what keeps them up at night (interview). Try it on three people you saw this week, and place each one on a level.
Level one: facts that open a story
Facts come first, and they’re useful. You can’t ask about someone’s worries before you know their name or their job. The trouble starts when the facts stop the conversation. “Where are you from?” gets “Ohio,” and the thread ends there.
A fact turns into something to follow when you ask for the story behind it. “You moved here from Ohio. What made you pick this city?” asks for a reason, and a reason can come with a scene. Words like “strangest” or “best” can make a question easier to answer with a story.
These questions stay on level one and still invite a story:
- How did you end up in this city?
- What’s the best part of your work on a good day?
- What’s something you’ve started doing in the last year?
Level two: goals and worries
Level two is where you start to know what drives someone. It sounds personal, and it is. It’s also the level of plans for the year, a project on the side, a decision someone keeps putting off.
The step up feels bigger than it is. In a series of experiments by Michael Kardas, Amit Kumar and Nicholas Epley, strangers expected deep conversations to feel more awkward than they did. They felt more connected to deep conversation partners than to shallow ones. The gap came from a wrong guess: people expected the other person to care less about what they shared than that person did (Kardas et al. 2021).
Each question here is an invitation. If someone says “I don’t have a big goal right now,” that’s a full answer, and it can lead somewhere too.
- What are you working toward this year?
- What’s taking up most of your head lately?
- Is there something you want to learn and haven’t started?
Level three: the story, and why it waits
Level three is the story someone tells about their own life. Where things turned. What they’ve survived. What they think they’re for. It can come out over time, with people who’ve already seen levels one and two.
Asking for it too early can land badly. “So what’s your story?” at a first meeting asks someone to sum up their life on the spot. Level three may be easier to reach once there’s trust. When a story starts, these questions help it unfold:
- When did your life take a turn you didn’t plan?
- Who shaped the way you see things?
- Looking back, what do you think you were looking for at 20?
Skipping a level can read as pressure. Staying on one forever can read as distance. The move that works is one step at a time, with room for the other person to stay where they are.
One word as the step between levels
A single word on the table lets each person pick their own level. Thesis is a deck built around that. You draw a card, choose a side, the idea or the thing, and say what the word brings up. The rules put it this way: “Say as much or as little as feels right.” The same word can stay a fact or turn into a story, and the person speaking decides.
The die adds an angle. Its six faces are MEMORIES · BODY · PEOPLE · VALUES · CHILDHOOD · FUTURE. Roll, then look at the word from that side.
Work has Stone on its other side. It’s a good card for level one: anyone can say what they do. The idea side can move up a step without effort, from the job to what work means to them. The stone keeps it light, a stone from a beach, a stone in a shoe.
Hope has Teddy bear on its other side. Hope sits on level two. It asks about the future without asking for a plan. The teddy bear is the way out: a story about a toy is a full turn.
Home has Spoon on its other side. Home can reach level three, where someone lived, where they left, where they feel at home now. A spoon can be a grandmother’s kitchen or a bad flat with one drawer. Both sides are allowed.
You can play on the free online table or with a word written on a napkin.
After someone answers, the rule card’s follow-ups keep it going without pushing:
What did that feel like? Who else was there? Has it always meant that to you?
The rules also say: “A short answer is a full answer. You can always ask for more.” That line covers all three levels.
Your next conversation
Pick one fact you already know about someone, and ask for the story behind it. That’s one step. If they take it, the next question can be about what they’re hoping for this year. If they don’t, stay on level one, and enjoy it.
More on the question that moves a story along: follow-up questions. For evenings with people you already know, see Thesis for friends. The cards above have their own pages: Work, Hope and Home. See the rules and the box, and the research behind the deck. For the step from level one, see the middle ground between small talk and deep talk. See also getting to know your partner again when you think you know it all.