Belonging in first-year classes: small conversations that help

It’s a few weeks into a first-year course. Students sit in the same seats as on day one, and some still don’t know the name of the person next to them. A sense of belonging in college students can grow out of small, repeated contact with classmates, and a class can schedule that contact. This guide covers six habits for the first weeks of term. Each one is short and works with a word written on the board. The free online table covers the rest.

What the research says about classmates and belonging

Three findings shape the habits below. They come from abstracts, so treat them as leads for your own class.

Classmates count. Sandstrom and Dunn tracked students’ daily contact with classmates. On days when students interacted with more classmates than usual, they reported more happiness and stronger feelings of belonging (Sandstrom and Dunn 2014). The study was about weak ties: acquaintances, the people students see in class.

Students are liked more than they think. Boothby and colleagues found that after a conversation, people underestimated how much their partner liked them. They called it the liking gap. It appeared among first-year college students getting to know their dorm mates, and it lasted for several months (Boothby et al. 2018). A student who leaves a pair task thinking “they found me boring” may be wrong.

Early doubts read differently when they’re framed as common. Walton and Cohen ran a randomized trial with 92 first-year students. A short exercise framed social difficulty in the first year as common and temporary, and students then generated the message themselves. Over three years, it raised the grades of African-American students (49 in the sample) relative to control groups and halved the minority achievement gap. The sample also included 43 European-American students. The authors trace the effect to how students read setbacks: a hard week stopped looking like proof that they didn’t belong (Walton and Cohen 2011). Their exercise was a specific, tested design. The habits below borrow only its central idea.

1. Keep the same small groups for several weeks

A student can’t build contact with a classmate they meet once. Put students in small groups early in the term and keep the groups for several weeks. Use them for every short task in that time. By the end of that stretch, each student has a few classmates whose names they know and who know theirs. Then reshuffle, so each student meets a new set of classmates during the term.

2. Open each session with one word, in the groups

A short round at the start gives the groups something to talk about besides the task. Write one word on the board. Each student says a sentence or two about it, and the others can ask one short question. Pick words with no right answer, so nobody has to know the material yet. Before the first round, agree on how passing works. The Thesis rules open with this line: “Before you start, agree together how passing works.” In a class, a pass costs nothing and needs no reason.

Belonging
Headphones
Card 44: Belonging / Headphones. Tap to turn it over.

Belonging has Headphones on its back. In a first-year class, the idea side brings out stories about a team, a club or a first week somewhere new. The Headphones side is the easier way in. A student can talk about what they listen to on the walk to campus, and that can be the first thing two classmates find they share.

3. Name the first-year dip before it arrives

The Walton and Cohen exercise worked through framing. Students read that hard weeks in the first year are common and pass, and then put the message into their own words. You can borrow the idea without running their study. Early in the term, ask the groups to talk about one thing that was harder than they expected this term. Go first with your own first-year example. Keep it short and end it with what changed later. The point is that students hear their classmates say the same thing they were thinking.

Home
Spoon
Card 49: Home / Spoon. Tap to turn it over.

Home has Spoon on its back. For students who moved away for college, Home brings up what they miss and what they’ve started to build in a new place. Students who still live with family can talk about the same word from the other side. The Spoon side keeps it light: a kitchen in a dorm, a meal someone cooks for their housemates, the food they bring back after a weekend away.

4. Close the gap after pair work

The liking gap means students leave conversations thinking they made a worse impression than they did. A closing round makes the other person’s view audible. The Thesis rules end each game this way: “each player names one thing they discovered about someone at the table today.” In class, give it a few minutes at the end of a session, once a week. Each student names one thing they learned from someone in their group. Hearing it said back is a direct sign that a classmate listened.

5. Make the instructor’s part small and steady

Walk between the groups during the opening round and listen, without joining every conversation. Learn names early in the term and use them when you hand back work. When a student misses a session, ask their group to send them a short note about what they did. Each of these is quick, and each tells the student that someone in the room noticed them.

6. Ask about belonging in conversation, as well as on a form

If your department runs a belonging survey, the form gives you a score, but students don’t get to know each other by filling it in. Use the questions below as group prompts once or twice in the term, with the free pass in place.

  1. Where on campus do you feel most at ease so far?
  2. Who’s someone in this class you didn’t know a month ago?
  3. What’s something that was harder than you expected this term?
  4. What’s a place outside campus that feels like yours?
  5. What helped you settle in somewhere new before?
  6. What’s a small thing that made a week go better?
  7. What would you tell someone starting here next year?
  8. What’s one group you’d like to be part of here?
Community
Mirror
Card 42: Community / Mirror. Tap to turn it over.

Community has Mirror on its back. It suits a first-year class in the middle of term, once students have something to point to: a study group, a team, a group chat for the course. The Mirror side lets a student talk about how they see themselves in a new place, at whatever depth they choose.

Running it as a card round

With the deck or the online table, a turn follows the same steps. Draw a card, choose the idea or the thing, roll the die and look at the word from that side. The die has six plain words: MEMORIES · BODY · PEOPLE · VALUES · CHILDHOOD · FUTURE. The only instruction is “Look at the word from that side.” The others can ask one short question. The rule card gives three examples: What did that feel like? Who else was there? Has it always meant that to you? The rule card also says: “A short answer is a full answer. You can always ask for more.”

Roll the die

For your next class, form the small groups and write one word on the board for the first round. The three cards above have their own pages: Belonging, Home and Community. For more on running it with a group, see Thesis for teams and classes. For the studies behind the deck, see the research. See the rules and the box. For a format that brings the same rounds to colleagues, see deep conversations at work. Related: first day of class icebreakers for college: a plan that lasts past day one.